So if you follow me on Twitter you’ll know that on Wednesday I took Joe to the doctor because he’s quite rubbish at walking (Joe, not the doctor). I wasn’t all that worried because he does walk, he just seems a bit lumbering and he falls over a lot (partly because he keeps trying to, you know, run before he can walk!) but I just thought I’d get him checked to be on the safe side.
Joe was walking around the waiting room and when the doctor opened his door, Joe toddled on through and the doctor said, “He’s walking very well!” I said, “Is he? Cos that’s why we’re here!” and he said something about Joe’s gait – a “rolling gait”, I think he said, which would make sense because Joe does have something about the Father Christmas in his walk. So the doctor said it was nothing to worry about, adding, “He’s just carrying a bit of extra weight” and then, looking at me, “Looks like it’s running in the family.” Or something like that. I was slightly taken aback and also had a moment of “ouch” but then I thought, well, fair enough. (I was actually more offended on poor little Joe’s behalf – Joe ain’t fat!)
When I got home, I tweeted about it because, you know, that’s what I do and I was met with a hail of outrage. Lots of people said it was unprofessional, others thought I should complain, another said it wouldn’t be okay if a man in the street it, so it’s not okay for the doctor to say it. And while it was very sweet that so many of my friends leapt to my defence, honestly, I was a bit bewildered. Because, you know what? I am carrying a bit of extra weight. More than a bit, in fact. According to my BMI, I’m obese. For my height, I could comfortably weigh three stone less than I do now (more than a quarter of my weight, in fact).
But more than that, the responses on Twitter acted like the doctor had insulted me. He hadn’t, he’d just baldly stated a fact. It wasn’t the most tactful thing anyone’s ever said and, yes, there’s an argument to be made that he shouldn’t have commented on my body at all, but he’s a doctor – my reaction would have been different if, say, the postman had said it. If I’d tweeted that he’d said, “Well done on losing the baby weight!” would people have been so outraged? I doubt it.
For me, it was like a lightbulb moment. A couple of people on Twitter said it would either have sent them straight to a binge or they would have immediately gone on a diet. And, in the past, it would have been the same for me. In the past, I would have cried. In the past, I probably would have been outraged. But in the past I was always trying to hide my weight. I didn’t want people to know I was fat. It’s probably part of the reason I love the internet so much – I’m not fat online. I’m just me. And when I’ve arranged to meet people I know online, one of the main things I worry about is “They’re going to be surprised at how fat I am.” But lately I’ve come to accept that I am fat. And that’s okay. Like I’ve said before, it doesn’t mean anything about me as a person, it’s not a character flaw – I’m just carrying a bit of extra weight.
You know when Berger tells Miranda “Maybe he’s just not that into you?” and the other girls are horrified and Miranda’s thrilled by it? That’s kind of how this feels to me. I’m fat. And that’s okay.
Hi Keris,
I’m with you – I really don’t understand the outrage. He’s your GP, it’s his job to talk about medical issues. Every doctor I’ve ever worked with would have said the same.
Hearing it from the postman would be less acceptable…
Well since that’s ALL he said, he didn’t really talk about medical issues, but yes, exactly!
As for the postman, since I showed him my special private area that time I’m not sure I could complain about him either…
What a great post, Keris. I wouldn’t have been outraged by the doctor because I’m so used to that brutal ‘Ooh, aren’t you fat?’ outspokenness here in France. People often say to me ‘Are you pregnant, or just fat?’ I’m not kidding. And really, they mean well. I’ve discovered that if I just cheerfully say ‘No, just fat!’ they don’t apologise, they just get on with their business. Because really they couldn’t care less.
Thanks, Claire. I’ve had that since having kids and I cheerfully say, “No, just fat!” too, which was also a big step for me. I think part of the problem is that we all do still secretly think it’s bad to be fat and so if someone calls you fat they’re automatically insulting you. In other cultures, it would be a compliment!
I’m a post-babies fatty too (and it was SO worth it!). Actually my youngest just started school and I’m getting slimmer because I can actually walk at an adults pace for the first time in 3 years. My genes need exercise, it seems.
I’ve noticed that on days I’m feeling good about my life (writing going well, children being gorgeous, mountain looking fabulous) the fat comments are no big deal. It’s only on rubbish days that it bothers me, and I don’t have too many of those!
Oh I was fat before too, Claire, but I’m much fatter now
You’re right about your reaction depending on mood too. I find if I’m pre-menstrual I’m much more negative about my body than at any other time. Often it’s one of the first signs that I’m due on – I think, “God, I’m so fat. I need to do something about my weight” and then I think, “Is my period due..?”
I think for me it was the *way* he said it. I wasn’t outraged because he said it at all and one of the tweets I sent to you was ‘there are ways of saying these things’. He is your doctor and he is there to tell you if you are overweight and should do something about it. I just think, well, there are better ways of saying it. Especially to a woman who’s had a baby recently (yeah I know, he’s nearly 2). I’m just speaking from personal experience I guess.
Great post by the way. x
Thank you. But the way he said it (as interpreted by you) was only the way I tweeted it (as interpreted by me). Do you know what I mean? He didn’t say it nastily, he was laughing. I thought he was just being a little bit cheeky. And he didn’t say I should do something about it, which I was actually pleased about because I’m extremely healthy in general as he knows since he only ever sees me when I bring the boys in! Does that make sense?
It’s like that awful Marie Claire article – one of the bits I found the most offensive was where she offered diet tips, like if you’re fat you’re also too stupid to know how to lose weight!
What a great post, and a great place to get to where you’re comfortable with your lot (as it were!). As one of the outraged on Twitter I’d like to say it was the way he said it (as I interpreted it, anyway). It didn’t seem diagnostic or even concerned – just unsolicited and a bit pejorative. And you did admit your feelings were a little hurt, so I think much of the outrage was in support of you.
I don’t think anyone likes being told they’re fat, especially in such an offhand way. But again, that’s how I interpreted it!
No, you’re right, Robyn. Like I said, my feelings were a little bit hurt because, you know, someone just told me I was fat! But it was really just a knee-jerk reaction because why should someone telling me I’m fat hurt me when I know I’m fat? Does that make sense?
“It didn’t seem diagnostic or even concerned – just unsolicited and a bit pejorative”
It wasn’t diagnostic or concerned – I’d literally just walked in the door – but I don’t agree that it’s pejorative. Why pejorative? That’s the point I was making in my reply to Claire’s comment. The only reason we perceive it as pejorative is because we think it’s bad to be fat and so someone telling us we’re fat must be insulting us.
But I really did appreciate the support, I hope it doesn’t sound like I didn’t. But I also noticed that out of maybe 30 replies, only two said, “You’re not fat!” (Even David said “Joe’s not fat!”)
Well I couldn’t possibly comment on your appearance given that we’ve not met in (eurgh) meatspace
But I think you’re *lovely*.
“It wasn’t diagnostic or concerned – I’d literally just walked in the door – but I don’t agree that it’s pejorative. Why pejorative?”
No, you’re right. It’s a catalyst and the rest is up to our internal filters. It is literally an observation. Your doctor didn’t say “you’re fat and HORRIBLE” so I guess the response was proportionate to our assumption of what was going on for you internally as a result of his saying that.
So, in summary, we may have jumped the gun but it’s only because we CARE
Oh, and you’re pretty.
Haha! Thanks! And I know it’s cos you care. I was touched by the responses, honestly, but I was still surprised.
And thanks for “meatspace”. Ew.
[...] Want To Be A Historian? (American, but made me titter) * My Son Is Gay by Nerdy Apple Bottom & And That’s Ok by Keris [...]
I must admit, I was more concerned that he thought Joe was fat. That’s not right.
He didn’t say “fat” though, he said, “carrying a bit of extra weight”, which, like many toddlers, he is. To be fair though, he is a bit of a rubbish doctor and I wouldn’t be at all surprised if at Joe’s two year check we get referred somewhere else.
[...] I was writing the last post – um, ages ago – I found myself fixated on one little bit – the words “I am [...]